Questions for the new Comboni Missionaries Superior General

Comboni Missionaries Superior General

The new Superior General of the Comboni Missionaries will be elected this week. The Mirfield 12 hope that he will make a clean break with the past and own up to the crimes of sexual abuse of minors and will take steps to work with the abused to make sure it can never happen again.

Here are some questions for the Comboni Missionaries and the new Superior General:-

1. Was Clerical child abuse discussed at General Chapter XVIII?

2. Why was Father Pinkman moved on after accusations of child abuse at Mirfield.

3. Why was Father Valmaggia moved on and thrown out of the Order to a parish in Como after accusations of child abuse?

4. Why was Father Romano Nardo brought back from Uganda in the Nineties after accusations of child abuse by Mark Murray? Why was Mark told that he would never be allowed near children again? Why were these accusations never reported to the police? Why will the Comboni Missionaries not allow West Yorkshire police permission to speak interview him?

5. What do they think of Pope Francis’s latest statement in the USA last week when he said that “The crimes of sexual abuse against children cannot be repeated” and that bishops who cover up sexual abuse of minors will be prosecuted? Do they agree with the Pope? Will they follow his instructions on the matter?

6. Will the new Superior General acknowledge that abuse took place? Will he apologise for it? Will he work with the victims to make sure it can never happen again? Will he pass over all the information that they have about the sexual abuse on their files to Italian and UK police?

Comboni Missionaries should listen to what Pope Francis has to say about Clerical Abuse. GOD WEEPS — by Brian Mark Hennessey. Message to the 2015 General Chapter of the Comboni Missionary Order

‘GOD WEEPS”  by Brian Mark Hennessey


  1. On the last day of his visit to the United States yesterday, Pope Francis said “God weeps”. He was not referring to wars that ravaged parts of the world, nor hunger, poverty and physical deprivation. He was referring to child sexual abuse within the Church by clerics of the Church. Saying that he held the suffering of Continue reading

Comboni Missionaries General Chapter XVIII Vote for Superior General

Comboni Missionaries General Chapter XVIII

A momentous event is taking place for the Comboni Missionaries (ex-Verona Fathers) in Rome this month.

They are having their their seldom held General Chapter when representatives of all the 1,700 Comboni Missionaries will be in Rome to look at where they have been, where they are now, and where they want to be in the future.

This is only the 18th General Chapter that they have held in their history of well over a hundred years.

It is a period of introspection for them.

Chapter General Council to Elect New Superior General

At this momentous occasion they will also elect a new Superior General, i.e. a new head of the Order.

For the Compboni Missionaries, it is like a Vatican Council and an election of a new Pope all rolled into one.

The present Superior General, Father Enrico Sanchez, will be stepping down. He, as well as other previous Superior Generals, like the UK’s own Father David Glenday, will assist in the preparations and voting for the office of the new Superior General.

Child Abuse at Seminary in Mirfield

It is not known whether the Comboni Missionaries will be talking about their history of Sexual Child Abuse of Minors at their seminary in Mirfield, Yorkshire during the Sixties and Seventies at their General Chapter and any new response to it.

Pope Francis said just this week in te USA “The crimes of sexual abuse against children cannot be repeated” and wants to punish bishops who have covered up sexual abuse of minors.

However, so far, the Comboni MIssionaries have snubbed and defied Pope Francis’s instructions and have failed to even acknowledge that sexual abuse took place, never mind apologised for it.

Comboni Missionaries Cover-Up of Sexual Abuse

They are also continuing to cover up the sexual abuse, hiding out Father Romano Nardo at their house in Verona and refusing permission for West Yorkshire Police to interview him.

Defying Pope Francis may come back to haunt them.

However, if they elect a new Superior General who is untainted by the crimes of the past and the cover-up of what Pope Francis calls ‘crimes’, they have an opportunity to move forward in tandem with Pope Francis and the rest of the Catholic Church.

New Comboni Missionaries Superior General

The Mifield 12, who received payouts of £120,000 last year from the Comboni Missionaries, and the others whose cases are current, are calling on the Comboni Missionaries to use this General Chapter, and the election of a new Superior General, to take this opportunity to put the past behind them.

Representatives of the Mirfield 12, and the others, are willing to meet the new Superior General at his earliest convenience to help put the stain of child sexual abuse behind them and to work out new processes that make sure that this can never happen again.

We wish the Comboni Missionaries good fortune in their choice of their new Superior General. This may be the most important election they have ever had and opportunity to move in step with Pope Francis and the Catholic Church.

The future doesn’t bear thinking about if they don’t take this opportunity to change direction.

Abuse Victims Ask Comboni Missionaries to Turn New Chapter

Comboni Missionaries and Sexual Child Abuse

The Comboni Missionaries worldwide have gathered in Rome for their XV111th General Chapter. It is taking place from August 29th to October 4th.

The 72 capitular representatives, 45 of whom are from Europe, 14 from the Americas and 13 from Africa, are representing over 1,700 Comboni Missionaries scattered throughout the world.

On September 29th and 30th they will elect their new supreme leader, the Superior General.

Comboni Missionary Seminary in Mirfield

Last year, the Comboni Missionaries paid out £120,000 (€166,000) to 12 men who claimed they were abused as children at the Comboni Missionaries seminary in Mirfield, England in the 1960s and 1970s.

They claim that they were 11 years old to 15 years old when they were repeatedly abused by three Comboni Missionaries, Fr John Pinkman, Father Domenico Valmaggia and Father Romano Nardo and a lay teacher, Michael Riddle, at the seminary. There are several other outstanding claims.

The men claim that the Comboni Missionaries have never admitted the abuse and have never apologised for it.

Indeed, they claim that there has been a cover-up of the abuse, even though those accused were sent away from the seminary or brought home from the missions in Africa when the accusations were first made at the time.

Father Romano Nardo and Yorkshire Police

Mark Murray went to Verona to confront his abuser, Father Roman Nardo, in the Comboni Missionaries house in Verona earlier this year.

Father Nardo had been brought home from the missions in Uganda when Mark first made his accusations in the mid-Nineties and Mark was told that he would be kept away from children.

UK police want to interview Father Nardo but have been refused permission by the Order who say he is not in good enough health to answer their questions.

The UK police say that they are satisfied that a crime has been committed and that they would have sought the arrest two of those Comboni Missionaries accused of abuse, Fr Pinkman from Liverpool and Fr Valmaggia from Como if they had been still alive.

They have been trying for years to extradite Father Nardo, who is from Pordenone, but to no avail.

Comboni Missionaries Chapter XVIII Election Council

Now Mark, and the others who were abused are asking that the Comboni Missionaries start afresh and elect someone who has been untainted by the abuse and subsequent cover-up.

Said Mark, “Pope Francis has apologised for the abuse in the Catholic Church and has demanded that others take action.

“However, the Comboni Missionaries have refused to even admit that any abuse took place and refuse to apologise to those to whom they had a duty of care”.

Pope Francis, Comboni Missionaries and Child Sexual Anuse

In his recent visit to the USA, Pope Francis said “The crimes of sexual abuse against children cannot be repeated.”

Said Gerry McLaughlin, another of the Mirfield 12, “We ask the Comboni Missionaries to make a clean break with the past and elect someone who has been untainted by the abuse and the subsequent cover-up.

“We ask them to elect someone who follows Pope Francis’s teaching on child abuse and who will work with the abused to make sure that the ‘crime of sexual abuse of children’ cannot happen again as Pope Francis wishes.

“The Mirfield 12 would ask that the new Superior General meets with them at his earliest convenience to discuss how we can all move forward in resolving the abuse issues at Mirfield”.

This is what the Pope said: “God Weeps’ for Victims of Priest Sexual Abuse”

Your Pope – the one you follow said: “God Weeps’ for Victims of Priest Sexual Abuse”

There was from the Pope:

  • no mention of:  “all you want is money” ( Vice Superior of your Mother House in Verona.(
  • no mention of: “they should move on”
  • no mention of: “they should forget what happened to them”
  • no mention of: “it all happened a long time ago”
  • no mention of: “there is no point in meeting with you”
  • no mention of: “you will be waiting in vain if you are waiting for an apology”  – Superior of your Mother House in Verona

There are many more….

Here is what the Pope did say:

Pope meets with sex-abuse victims, promises accountability

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — Pope Francis met with victims of child sexual abuse Sunday on the final day of his U.S. visit and promised to hold accountable those responsible for the scandal in the church, delivering a powerful warning to American bishops accused of covering up for pedophile priests instead of reporting them to police

The pontiff disclosed the gesture of reconciliation at the start of a meeting with American bishops gathered in Philadelphia for a big rally on Catholic families.

But in a move that signaled a new effort by the church to redirect the discussion, the Vatican said not all five of the victims were abused by members of the clergy; some of the three women and two men had been victimized by family members or educators.

Francis praised the victims as “true heralds of mercy” who deserve the church’s gratitude for their “essential contribution” toward establishing the truth. Saying sex abuse in the church can no longer be kept a secret, he promised to “zealously” protect young people and see that “all those responsible are held accountable.”

The pope has agreed to create a new Vatican tribunal to prosecute bishops who failed to protect their flock by covering up for pedophile priests.

It was his second such meeting: Last summer he met at the Vatican with a group of victims of child-molesting priests.

But Francis and U.S. bishops have also argued that child molestation is a serious problem beyond the church, especially within families and in schools. The pope’s meeting with victims abused by people other than priests underscored that point.

The Archdiocese of Philadelphia has been hit hard by the scandal and has been the subject of repeated grand jury investigations, including one that accused it keeping on assignment more than three dozen priests facing serious abuse accusations. A monsignor was found guilty of endangering children by not removing pedophile priests, becoming the first American church official convicted of such an offense.

Victims’ groups had complained earlier in the week that Francis had neglected to address their plight when he congratulated bishops for their “courageous” and generous response to the scandal. Sunday’s meeting took place a day after the pope celebrated Mass with Justin Rigali, the cardinal who was archbishop in Philadelphia when the archdiocese was accused of sheltering pedophiles.

The Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, said the pope met with the survivors for a half-hour at the San Carlo Borromeo seminary. He said the pope prayed with them, listened to their stories and expressed his closeness in their suffering and his “pain and shame” in the case of those abused by priests.

“He renewed his commitment and that of the church so that victims are heard and treated with justice, that the guilty are punished and that the crimes of abuse are fought with efficient prevention efforts in the church and society,” Lombardi said in a statement. “The pope thanked the victims for their essential contribution to establish the truth and begin the path of healing.”

Comboni Missionaries General Chapter XVIII & Superior General Election

Comboni Missionaries General Chapter XVIII and General Council

The Comboni Missionaries top brass are assembled in Rome for their General Chapter XVIII. This is a vey important event for them. At the end of the Chapter the GeneralCouncilwill elect a new leader, the new Superior General.The current one, Father Enrico Sanchez will step down. Others who have held the role include the UK Province’s Father David Glenday. The General Chpater is taking place from Aigust 29th to October 4th.

Frs Martin Devenish, Provincial Superior and Tesfamichael are representing the UK Province in Rome at the General Chapter along with Comboni delegates from around the world.

Pope Francis and the Comboni Missionaries

The European Delegates put out the following statement: “We welcome the invitation of Pope Francis to become more and more a missionary Church, and for ourselves as Comboni Missionaries, to re-discover the joy of being missionary disciples in this Europe that is changing rapidly, and to overcome a certain pastoral tiredness and the temptation to withdraw into sterile pessimism.

“Aware that today missionary activity still represents the greatest challenge for the Church and that as Comboni Missionaries we are called – as was already said in the last Chapter of 2009 – to get out of our ‘comfort zone’ and have the courage to reach all the margins that need the light of the Gospel.

The Gospel According to Pope Francis

“We put ourselves in an attitude of searching to understand how to be missionary disciples in Europe today. In light of the call of Pope Francis, we wish to live the dream of God for the world, and be missionaries who go forth, ready to take on a new style beyond the soulless cliché of “We have always done it like that” (EG, No. 33), in order to open ourselves with confidence and courage to the challenges that come from the world of today, to read the Gospel starting from the margins, from the least and the excluded, and really have the “smell of sheep” (EG, No. 24).

“There is a people that awaits us and this requires a continuous ‘going out’ afresh on our part, and demands that we are bold and creative, and that we find new ways of proclamation, of closeness to the poor, of openness and of creativity in catechesis, in Missionary Animation and in the proclamation of the Gospel.”

Fr Martin Devenish, the General Counicl and General Chapter

IFr Martin Devenish, the UK Provincial Superior, wrote a letter to all the members of the London Province. It said: ‘The General Council earnestly invites all the Confreres to pray in a special way over the coming weeks for the forthcoming General Chapter so that the very important moment in the life of our Congregation may become an opportunity for each of us to live our missionary vocation more intensely.

“And the members of the Chapter may truly discern what the Lord wants of us today as his missionary disciples following in the footsteps of our Father and Founder, Daniel Comboni.

“During the deliberations in Rome a new General Council is elected. Our belated congratulations to the newly-elected team”.

Elect a Superior General Untainted By Sexual Abuse of Minors

Let’s hope that the new leader of the Comboni Missionaries, the new Superior General, will be untainted by the sexual abuse scandal of the past or the cover ups which have cointinue dto this day.

Let’s hope that he takes a new broom approach and acknowledges that the abuse took place, apologizes for it like Pope Francis has done, and will work with the abused to put in place processes which will both prevent this happening again and pursue those who took part in the abuse or covered it up.

“providing help for victims” – Pope Francis told the bishops, who applauded.

Pope Francis on Wednesday told U.S. Roman Catholic bishops that crimes of sexual abuse of minors by clergy should never be repeated, acknowledging the damage caused by years of scandal in the U.S. Catholic Church.

In the remarks, delivered at Saint Matthews Cathedral in Washington on the first full day of his visit to the United States, the pope did not utter the words “sexual abuse” but referred to the scandal by talking about “difficult moments” and providing help for victims.

“I know how much the pain of recent years has weighed upon you, and I have supported your generous commitment to bring healing to victims … and to work to ensure that such crimes will never be repeated,” Francis told the bishops, who applauded.

Wounds from the scandal, which saw priests who abused children moved from parish to parish instead of being defrocked, are still festering and draining church finances.

The U.S. church has already been dealt a heavy financial blow by settlement payments and other costs totalling around US$3 billion, which has forced it to sell off assets and cut costs.

The pontiff has vowed to root out “the scourge” of sex abuse from the Roman Catholic Church, and last June created a Vatican tribunal to judge clergy accused of covering up or failing to prevent sexual abuse of minors.

Victims’ groups say the church has not done enough.

On Wednesday, David Clohessy, head of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, who himself was sexually assaulted by a priest as a child, said he was unimpressed by Francis’ words.

“It’s dreadfully disappointing. Bishops have been cowardly, not courageous, and still are,” Clohessy said. “What grudging, belated steps they have taken have been forced on them by the most courageous people in this crisis, abuse victims and their families.”

Clohessy said Francis “refuses to even be honest about what this crisis is. These are not quote-unquote ‘difficult moments,’ this is a centuries-old, incredibly unhealthy and self-surviving pattern of secrecy and recklessness,” Clohessy said in a phone interview after the pope’s remarks.

During his six days in the United States, the pope may meet privately with victims of sexual abuse. The Vatican has said an eventual meeting would be announced after it takes place in order to protect the privacy of the victims.

(Reporting by Susan Cornwell and Philip Pullella; additional reporting by Scott Malone; Editing by Susan Heavey and Grant McCool)

– Reuters

The Comboni Chapter — “Living in Todays World”

It would have been a positive  opportunity if some of the men that suffered sexual abuse at Mirfield had been invited to talk and discuss their feelings, and the feelings of others, at the Comboni Missionaries Chapter taking place now in Rome.

That is what Pope Francis would have wanted, and that is what many priests and brothers of the Comboni Order want. It is what many of the abused want.

Chapter 2015

In accordance with n. 147 of the Rule of Life, with joy and trust in God we officially convoke the XVIII General Chapter of the Institute. This act calls all of us to set ourselves on a journey of discernment, communion and prayer with the enthusiasm of Comboni, so that the upcoming Chapter may be for our Institute a grace-filled event and an occasion of renewal. The XVIII General Chapter will take place in Rome, at the General Curia. The Chapter Delegates will have to be in Rome by Saturday 29 August 2015 for a week of preparation. The Chapter will open on Sunday 6 September 2015 with a solemn Eucharist at 9 a.m. and its closing date is foreseen for Sunday 4 October 2015 with a solemn Eucharist. The theme for the XVIII General Chapter is: “The Comboni missionary disciples called to live the joy of the Gospel in today’s world”. Superior General, Fr. Enrique Sánchez González, and his Council.

Chapter’s Documents: Letters of Superior General and his Council (Letter of Convocation, guidelines, lists of Delegates, and so on), Chapter Acts, and so one.

Study works and essays concerning the General Chapter.

The pre-Chapter commission: Fr. Rogelio Bustos Juárez (Mexico, coordinator of the Commission); Fr. José da Silva Vieira (Portugal); Fr. Miguel Pedro Andrés (Spain); Fr. Peter Ciuciulla (Chad); Fr. Joseph Mumbere Musanga (Congo); Fr. Dario Bossi (Brazil); Bro. Alberto Degan (Italy); and Fr. John Richard Kyankaaga Ssendawula (Egypt-Sudan).

“Summary Topics for Discernment”

Official Press Releases

https://www.facebook.com/Laici-Missionari-Comboniani-189169117802667/timeline/

Time for discernment in the XVIII General Chapter in Rome. After the first phase dedicated to listening to what is happening on the ground in our institute, the Chapter begins the time of discernment in order to identify the priorities of our mission as combonis. Yesterday the “phase of seeing” has come to an end after listening to the reports which started on Thursday 10 September. The first report was that of the General council read by our superior general Father Enrique Sanchez, followed by the reports of the general secretariats and the Comboni Curia offices, and by those coming from the continents: Francophone Africa, America and Asia, Anglophone Africa and lastly Europe.

Mirfield…..it was the place I lost me, the person I was, the person I would have become. By Boy X

Mirfield…..it was the place I lost me, the person I was, the person I would have become. By Boy X

I must admit I haven’t given much thought to the Comboni missionaries failure to acknowledge what happened in Mirfield. I suppose I have been totally absorbed with my own attempts to come to terms with what happened, trying to find a place in my mind where I can find some way of moving forward. I think I have done that to some extent.

I suppose I’ve been caught up with the over-riding need that I know can never be satisfied. But knowing that, won’t make the need disappear. That need being a sincere apology from my abuser. It’s said that the eyes are the mirror of the soul. I’ve dreamed about it, seeing in my dreams the sincerity in his eyes just as clearly as I saw that look of desire in his eyes when he first put his hands on me. A look I saw in the eyes of many others after leaving Mirfield. I recognised it straight away.

But those eyes are now dead, so I wonder where that leaves me. At the moment, it leaves me where I have always been, Mirfield. I have been able after a lot of thinking and prompting to offset, to some extent, the bad things, by remembering that there were some good things too in Mirfield. I especially remember now those feelings that were special. They had nothing to do with people, not Fr. Pinkman nor Ceresoli not even my friends. Those feeling were about why I was there in Mirfield. I knew why I was there. Those feelings were only short lived but it does bring some solace remembering them. It’s good to remember that I was once in a place in my life that was so different to what the rest of my life became. Of course, it then just becomes a confusion of thoughts. If things had been different I may have ended up having a very comfortable life on the other side of the fence. Maybe a life that would have been too comfortable to give up. Maybe I would have become one of those who are willing to turn their backs on the abused, One of those who give refuge to evil. What an awful place that would have been to end up in.

I suppose finding some release from the things that destroyed my life might only be temporary, I don’t know. The bad things are eternal but maybe in a strange way, looking to Mirfield to gain some release may be fitting. It was the place I lost me, the person I was, the person I would have become. That’s all I will say about that.

When it comes to the question of the Comboni missionaries failure to acknowledge what happened at Mirfield, the answers come easier. Their failures make them apologists for child abuse. Their inaction makes them complicit in what took place and that inaction is ensuring that the horrors of the past will continue and that there will always be a refuge for the perpetrators of evil. There will always be a ‘safe house’ for them.

I feel quite helpless in a way. But I suppose that is only to be expected seeing as. like I said at the beginning, I haven’t given the whole thing much thought. Maybe it’s time for me think outside myself. I’ll see where it takes me. Maybe the Comboni missionaries can apologise to me vicariously on Fr. Pinkman behalf but maybe they have enough on their plates with their own evil deeds never mind anyone else’s. But of course it’s all part of the same thing. I know I could do a lot more myself if only I could overcome the hurdle of the need to still remain anonymous. I suppose the shame and guilt still has it’s grip on me. No amount of rational thought seems to diminish that.

Boy X